The Collectors’ Journal — Vol. 04
The vintage is only half the story.
Open two bottles of Dom Pérignon 1985, one from the original release and one from the Oenothèque collection, and you may find remarkably different wines. Same vintage, same producer, same original blend. The difference? When the cork went in.
Few other wines make the relationship between time and taste quite so complicated.
1. Champagne owes its existence to a prehistoric ocean
The chalk beneath Champagne’s vineyards consists largely of the remains of microscopic marine organisms deposited millions of years ago. A cubic metre of this chalk can hold between 300 and 400 litres of water.
Its ability to drain excess rainfall while retaining water for dry periods is particularly valuable in a region where growing conditions have historically been unpredictable.
But Champagne is not one enormous chalk vineyard. The Kimmeridgian marls of the Côte des Bar share more geological similarities with Chablis than with the Côte des Blancs. Interestingly, these soils predominantly support Pinot Noir in Champagne and Chardonnay in Chablis.
Terroir is rarely as straightforward as we would like it to be.

2. The best Champagne doesn’t necessarily have a vintage
In Bordeaux or Burgundy, blending three different harvests into a flagship wine would be unthinkable. In Champagne, it can produce some of the region’s most sought-after bottles.
Jacques Selosse Extra Brut V.O. combines three consecutive harvests of Chardonnay from hillside vineyards in Avize, Cramant and Oger.
Anselme Selosse approached Champagne with ideas influenced by his training in Burgundy: individual vineyards, barrel fermentation and a greater emphasis on the character of the base wine.
His intention was not simply to compensate for weaker vintages through blending, but to express something more permanent than the character of a single growing season.
It raises an interesting question: can removing the signature of a particular year actually make terroir more recognisable?
3. The secret behind Winston Churchill’s Champagne
Pol Roger has never disclosed the exact proportions of Pinot Noir and Chardonnay in its Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill.
What we do know is that the grapes come exclusively from Grand Cru vineyards already planted during Churchill’s lifetime, and that Pinot Noir dominates the blend.
The wine undergoes full malolactic fermentation, converting the sharper malic acid into softer lactic acid. A reminder that Champagne does not necessarily need the highest possible acidity to age successfully.
The second fermentation takes place at just 9°C, in cellars extending 33 metres beneath Épernay. Pol Roger even continues to riddle its bottles by hand, a practice largely replaced elsewhere by automated machinery.
The Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill 2018 represents a particularly interesting proposition: a generous, warm vintage interpreted by a house that deliberately favours structure and maturity.
4. A forty-year-old Champagne can have a surprisingly young cork
The Dom Pérignon Oenothèque Commande Spéciale 1985 in our collection was disgorged in 2004.
It has therefore spent roughly two decades ageing before disgorgement and another two decades under its final cork.
During ageing on the lees, Champagne evolves through yeast autolysis and gradual oxidation. Once disgorged, the sediment is removed, dosage is added where appropriate and a different phase of development begins.
A late-disgorged Champagne can consequently retain a remarkable sense of freshness compared with an original release of the same vintage.
That does not automatically make it superior. Some collectors actively prefer the nutty, savoury and sometimes almost Burgundian character of Champagne that has spent decades under its final cork.
If you ever have the opportunity to taste both releases side by side, take it. Few comparative tastings illustrate the importance of maturation quite so clearly.

5. There is scientific evidence for buying magnums
In 2023, researchers examined thirteen Champagne vintages that had matured for between 25 and 47 years, comparing standard bottles with magnums.
The magnums retained significantly more dissolved carbon dioxide.
Champagne gradually loses CO₂ through its closure, even before disgorgement. With twice the volume of wine and a similar bottle-neck diameter, a magnum loses proportionally less.
This also helps explain why an old Champagne can have very little remaining effervescence without necessarily being defective.
For collectors planning to open their wines several decades from now, bottle size may prove almost as consequential as vintage.
6. Is zero dosage really better?
The popularity of Extra Brut and Brut Nature has encouraged the idea that less sugar means greater purity.
Yet dosage is not simply a matter of sweetness. The liqueur added at disgorgement can contain mature reserve wines, adding another dimension to the finished Champagne.
A wine with seven grams of sugar per litre can taste drier than one with three, depending on its acidity, concentration and maturity.
Judging Champagne by its dosage alone is rather like judging Barolo by its alcohol percentage: a useful piece of information, but hardly a verdict on quality.
When buying mature Champagne, there are three questions worth asking before looking at a critic’s score.
When was it disgorged? How has it been stored? And in what format?
The vintage is a good place to start. It is rarely the whole answer.